The 88% death rate was among patients who either died or recovered. It did not account for roughly three-quarters of patients involved in the study.
It’s easy to hook readers with a shocking statistic, and I recently saw one that left my jaw hanging. But then I saw that PolitiFact gave it a closer look.
A recent study garnered headlines when it reported a high mortality rate for patients on ventilators in one New York health care network.
The study, published in the prestigious Journal of the American Medical Association, followed 5,700 coronavirus patients who had been admitted to 12 Northwell Health hospitals in metropolitan New York between March 1 and April 4.
The finding that painted the grimmest picture, and attracted the most media attention, was about the likelihood that patients put on ventilators would die. Ventilators are medical devices that help patients with compromised lung function continue to breathe. Patients are connected to the ventilator through a breathing tube inserted into the airway, a procedure known as intubation.
The study found that only 38 ventilator patients recovered and were released, compared with 282 who died. That works out to a death rate of 88%.
But there was an important detail that got glossed over in some of the initial coverage: 831 patients remained in the hospital and were excluded from the calculation. That’s more than 72% of all the patients involved in the study. So for the vast majority of patients studied, the jury is still out on whether they will recover.
Beaches are reopening. Images of crowded beaches are everywhere. What does this mean for fact-checking?
As beaches reopen across the country, these tools and tips will help you separate real pictures from false or out-of-context images. Read more»
Trump says N95 masks can be sterilized for reuse
Experts uniformly agree that sterilized respirator masks aren’t as protective as new ones — and that reusing masks should be considered an emergency measure. Read the fact-check»
The international supply chain behind coronavirus testing
Supply chain problems are driving the lack of testing for the novel coronavirus. The U.S. outsources some of the materials it needs for testing. Get the facts»
How to put COVID-19 data in context
There are a lot of coronavirus statistics out there — number of cases, number of those tested, death rate. Author and MediaWise ambassador John Green explains how to navigate data and infographics. Watch the video»
by Alex Mahadevan, Poynter